Legal & Compliance
ADA Website Lawsuit Settlements: What Companies Actually Pay
With over 4,600 federal accessibility lawsuits filed in 2024, businesses need to understand the real costs of non-compliance. Here's what companies pay to settle ADA website lawsuits—and how to avoid becoming the next defendant.
$25K
Median settlement
$150K+
Enterprise settlements
$50K
Typical legal fees
6-18mo
Resolution timeline
The Reality of ADA Website Settlements
Most ADA website lawsuits never go to trial. Over 95% of cases settle before reaching a courtroom, which means the true cost of non-compliance is determined by negotiation—not by jury verdicts. Understanding what companies actually pay helps you assess your risk and make informed decisions about accessibility investment.
Settlement amounts vary dramatically based on company size, website complexity, the severity of accessibility barriers, and the plaintiff's legal representation. A small business facing a first-time demand letter pays very differently than a Fortune 500 company defending repeat litigation.
What's consistent: the total cost of a lawsuit always exceeds what proactive compliance would have cost. Businesses that invest in accessibility before receiving a demand letter save significantly compared to those who react to litigation.
Settlement Ranges by Business Size
Small Business (Under $5M Revenue)
Settlement range:
$5,000 - $25,000
Legal fees:
$10,000 - $30,000
Remediation cost:
$5,000 - $15,000
Total exposure:
$20,000 - $70,000
Small businesses are often targeted by serial plaintiff firms who know they'll settle quickly to avoid legal costs. Demand letters typically request $10,000-$15,000 plus remediation commitments.
Mid-Market ($5M - $100M Revenue)
Settlement range:
$25,000 - $100,000
Legal fees:
$30,000 - $75,000
Remediation cost:
$15,000 - $50,000
Total exposure:
$70,000 - $225,000
Mid-market companies face more scrutiny. Plaintiffs often cite the company's revenue in settlement demands. Cases may involve consent decrees requiring ongoing compliance monitoring.
Enterprise ($100M+ Revenue)
Settlement range:
$100,000 - $500,000+
Legal fees:
$75,000 - $300,000
Remediation cost:
$50,000 - $250,000
Total exposure:
$225,000 - $1,000,000+
Large enterprises face class action potential and significant reputational risk. Settlements often include third-party auditors, ongoing compliance reports, and mandatory accessibility training.
What Settlement Agreements Include
ADA website settlements typically include multiple components beyond the monetary payment. Understanding these terms helps you prepare for negotiations and plan remediation efforts.
Monetary Components
- • Direct damages: Payment to the plaintiff (typically $5,000-$25,000)
- • Attorney's fees: Plaintiff's legal costs (often $15,000-$50,000)
- • California Unruh damages: $4,000+ per violation if in California
- • Injunctive relief costs: Third-party auditing and monitoring
Remediation Requirements
- • WCAG 2.1 AA compliance: Required within 6-18 months
- • Third-party audit: Independent verification of compliance
- • Accessibility statement: Published policy with contact info
- • Staff training: Accessibility training for web team
Ongoing Obligations
- • Monitoring period: 2-3 years of compliance reporting
- • User testing: Regular testing with disabled users
- • Compliance reports: Quarterly or annual submissions
- • Non-breach provisions: Additional penalties for violations
Notable Settlement Examples
Public settlement data reveals what major companies have paid—and what they agreed to do:
Major Retail Chain
$6.8MClass action settlement covering website and mobile app accessibility. Included 3-year compliance program, user testing, and third-party monitoring.
Domino's Pizza
UndisclosedLandmark case establishing website accessibility under ADA. Settlement required full WCAG 2.0 AA compliance for website and mobile app.
National Restaurant Group
$250,000Settled after online ordering system found inaccessible to screen readers. Required accessibility training for development team.
E-commerce Fashion Retailer
$75,000First-time defendant settled demand letter within 60 days. Avoided litigation by agreeing to remediation timeline and compliance audit.
Hidden Costs Beyond Settlement
The settlement amount is only part of the total cost. Businesses facing ADA website lawsuits also pay for:
🔧 Emergency Remediation
Rush development work to fix accessibility issues costs 2-3x normal rates. $15,000-$75,000 typical.
👨💼 Executive Time
Leadership attention diverted from business priorities. Depositions, strategy meetings, board updates.
📊 Insurance Premium Increases
E&O and cyber liability premiums may increase 10-30% after accessibility claims.
📰 Reputation Damage
Public lawsuits generate negative coverage. Disability advocacy groups may amplify criticism.
What You Can Do Now
The most cost-effective strategy is preventing lawsuits before they happen. Here's how to reduce your risk:
- 1. Assess your current state: Run an automated accessibility scan to identify obvious issues. Tools like RatedWithAI provide instant WCAG compliance reports.
- 2. Fix critical issues first: Address missing alt text, form labels, and keyboard navigation—these are the most-cited issues in lawsuits.
- 3. Publish an accessibility statement: Shows good faith effort and provides a mechanism for feedback before litigation.
- 4. Create a remediation roadmap: Document your plan to achieve WCAG 2.1 AA compliance with timeline and milestones.
- 5. Train your team: Ensure designers and developers understand accessibility requirements for new features.
The Math Is Clear
Proactive accessibility compliance costs $5,000-$30,000 for most businesses. Lawsuit defense costs $50,000-$200,000+. Investing in accessibility now is 3-10x cheaper than reacting to litigation later.
Know your risk
Is your website lawsuit-ready?
Scan your site for accessibility issues before plaintiff attorneys find them. Get a WCAG compliance report in minutes.